You have their TG usernames and you can see all list of judges in gov.freeton.org
you recieve about 3k$ every month for this job, why you want more tokens? :))
1 Like
Я абсолютно уверена, что судьи должны нести ответственность за свои оценки. Я в шоке от грязи и лжи в комментариях. Я так понимаю, судьи сводят личные счеты с участниками? Просто потому, что кто-то не нравится? Это низкий поступок и за это нужно отвечать.
I am absolutely convinced that judges should be held accountable for their marks. I am shocked by the dirt and lies in the comments. As far as I understand, the judges settle personal scores with the participants? Just because someone doesn’t like it? This is a low act and one must answer for it.
“appreciate your help in the various SubGs - 2 pts”
Thanks dude!!!)))
2 Likes
- Я не утверждаю, что сделал много, ту малость, что сделал - поместил в свой сабмишн (#1). На высокие оценки не претендую.
- Имхо, конкурс не является мотивацией - а является сугубой профанацией идеи. Вы можете соглашаться или не соглашаться с этим, но это мое мнение и я имею полное право его озвучить, хотя бы в рамках пресловутой декларируемой “децентрализации” (здесь скептически улыбающийся смайлик).
- Почему профанация - описал выше в посте. Двойные стандарты и лицемерие сами знаете кого в комментах. У всех без исключения можно найти тем самые озвученные в комментах “дабл-дип”, но в оценке одних это плохо-плохо и низкий балл, а для других - это так, на полшишечки и десятка. Потому что ребята хорошие и много работают.
Я не отрицаю, что ребята хорошие и работают много. Это действительно так. Но зачем устраивать этот гребаный цирк с подобными контестами?
Хорошие ребята работают много - так платите им достойную оплату за ВСЮ их работу. Это будет правильно и хорошо. Это и будет мотивация.
А подобные контесты с двойными стандартами - это никакая не мотивация. Ну вы сами видите по комментариям в данном треде.
Надеюсь лично вас я ничем не оскорбил и вы не станете тереть мои комменты? Я просто имею собственное мнение и право его высказать, равно как и прочие здесь.
1 Like
Judge 0:5413c6e270992e1123b7fbf6bb5ea6610e44763b9fb1a62149bffbd62b37e260
Your comments are dirty lies from start to finish.
You wrote: Helped organize the Dubai event? Liar.
What? 
I wrote that I helped organize the event in Dubai? Seriously? Did you open my submission at all? The only page that mentions the event is here:
Do you understand what it means «I did not take part in organizing this event?»
You wrote: Helped organize the 1-year anniversary event? Yes, you got paid for it, which is a travesty in itself.
What? Seriously? I was paid, but I don’t know about it? Have you read my submission? There is a link to a report on the forum with the results of the event. Duplicate here: Free TON Anniversary Celebration - #90 by amalfica
Do you see this? The budget deficit was 10 383 TON Crystal.
In this regard, almost the entire organization team worked for free.
You must pay everyone who organized the event. The whole team. If you prove that we received money for this earlier, we will return it to you.
2 Likes
On the last page of my submission there is a phrase:
Let’s meet more often, I’m ready to do equally cool events.
Perhaps I take my words back. The whole team worked like crazy people. I worked non-stop for almost 3 months. And for this I get filth and accusations? And the lie that I was paid?
It is very unpleasant for me that I have to waste my time on this.
So, here’s what we found out. The data of the judges of this contest suddenly turned out to be “classified”. Surprise. 
On gov.freeton.org there are public keys of judges (for each competition) and we just have to match the usernames of the judges and their addresses and / or public keys.
Here’s what we managed to find so far:
| Username | Address |
|---|---|
| Ronmillow | 0:5413c6e270992e1123b7fbf6bb5ea6610e44763b9fb1a62149bffbd62b37e260 |
| LuminaRash | |
| Dima_xem | |
| chuorinkan | |
| ignatshapkin | |
| sergesmalko | |
| antonzur | |
| noBapnymuHa | 0:92beb59642d06a59615531b23b5139ac023bfa6acd29597ca2f758d0b82fe170 |
| Riemann | 0:cf04e2a4c2755e114d906322afbdbab71d51aa8abaeae9c5983764127dc360c9 |
| casper_ru | |
| djimst | |
| stormbreaker_Thor | |
| ZehanT |
I also sent a message via Surf to the address of each judge (except the recognized ones) with this text:
Hi, please tell me your username or nickname on the forum.freeton.org in a reply message or PM me telegram @everjob. This is necessary for public monitoring of the voting results for Contest Proposal: DeSupport 2021 Part I.
If the judges are going to judge objectively, then it will not be a problem for them to answer me, as I hope.
Let me know here if you know the details of any of the judges so that I can update the table above.
1 Like
Publicizing juror info is absolutely the work of people who do not understand that this is the equivalent of jury tampering. For this there will be a proposal put forth to disqualify you from the contest entirely. Bad move. I strongly advise you to delete this information.
I think what we need now is a really thorough analytics report on the Wiki Subgovernance.
4 Likes
This is not organizing a thing. You participated at the Dubai event like everyone else and you WERE PAID FOR IT! You do not get to ask to get paid twice for the same work. As to the 1-year anniversary, fine. It doesn’t change a thing. The bulk of your submission is for work you get rewards for already.
Now that you decided to tamper with the jury and publicize private information, there will be a proposal put forth to remove your submissions and disqualify you for attempting to influence the jury.
Great work! As always. 
Epic fail.
3 Likes
ты серьезно считаешь что ты должен что-то получить в этом контесте? ты каждый месяц получаешь зарплату в ДОЛЛАРАХ за все то, что ты перечислил и сейчас еще имеешь моральное право что-то писать?
позор 
2 Likes
Again. I did NOT write that I took part in the event in Dubai. I put a picture of us all there because it was so damn great to see everyone. And that I am ready to organize any other interesting events. Read my submission, there is not a word about Dubai, only a picture at the end.
But I already changed my mind about doing events, thanks to you.
What does it mean “fine”? Is this your apology? You wrote dirty words to me in the comments, called me a liar and said that I received money (when I did not receive). And when it turns out that you are lying, you write “fine”?? 
Be a man, apologize for your deed. Not only in front of me, but also in front of the whole team, who did not receive a single TON for organizing the event in Moscow. And who did you give a low grade to.
Being an adult means taking responsibility for your actions. And do not write “fine” if you are wrong.
Is this secret information? Why is the information about the names and addresses of the jury of all SG in the public domain? 
Either everything must be secret, or everything must be open publicly. Let’s decide.
You forgot. We publish a detailed report for each TON every month on the forum. And we are the only sabgs who do it.
This is very strange to hear, because the information about the members and judges of all Subgovenances has always been public and is updated in this spreadsheet: Governance_Juries - Google Sheets
Tell me at what point there was a ban on the publication of the data of the judges of this contest? Is there a proposal with this solution? Please give me a link to the accepted proposal and I’ll delete that post above.
Upd: I also did not find anything in the contest proposal that the data of the judges should be hidden from the community. And I saved the contest proposal pdf in case of surprises.
I also put forward a proposal to disqualify you as a judge. You put unreasonable estimates on several applications (I can make a list) and wrote lies in the comments. These estimates are based on nothing but your hate.
And yes, you did not read my submission. There is a link to a report on the forum with the results of the event. There is information that we did not receive a cent (or ton). But you didn’t notice it, did you?
@XLR25t By the way, you NEVER took part in the project’s contests. You weren’t a contestant. You are only a judge and you only know one side. And it gives you permissiveness. You think you’re always right. This is a very sad experience. You need to get on the other side.
I think the judges should have experience of participating in other contests as a participant.
I’m done with the two of you. The whole community knows what you’re up to and how you operate. After this insane move, it’s time to make everything transparent. Not going to go back and forth with you two. You made a big mistake by publicizing jury info. That was the red line. Everyone has had enough.
4 Likes
Good luck with that. Your arrogance in the face of a con game is amazing. You have no moral brakes.
The jury has been made aware. Any attempt to publicize more of their info or to contact them directly will result in further proposals to take action.