#12 Wiki Renewal Contest Proposal [17.12 – 19.12.2020]

aicracy · December 14, 2020, 7:46pm

And the judges are interested in herd voting for and not against

In theory, they could even negotiate such behavior behind the scenes.
For my taste the reward must not be in any relation with that, how you vote. Except may be “abstain”.

bitjudge · December 14, 2020, 8:00pm

I see that you don’t understand the voting reward mechanism. The reward of the judges does NOT depend on the vote. Your fears are unfounded, because there is nothing of what you write here.

aicracy · December 14, 2020, 8:11pm

Well. That is the direct and only on possible conclusion from that text:

The actual reward will range from 0 to your claimed Tons, inclusive , depending on the quality of your work and the final jury score. Rejected submission will not receive any reward.

Each reward depends on score -> sum of all rewards depends on score -> jurors reward (5%) depends on score.

bitjudge · December 14, 2020, 8:15pm

No. This paragraph refers to the rewards of the participants in the contest and does not apply to the rewards of the jury. Jury rewards in another section.

aicracy · December 14, 2020, 8:19pm

Ok. I’ll try it in another way. Can you predict the final budget of your contest?

bitjudge · December 14, 2020, 8:50pm

I can’t see the future and I don’t make predictions.
As for the data from past contests, it is published here.

aicracy · December 14, 2020, 8:59pm

You agree if I say that the higher the final average score, the higher the final budget?

aicracy · December 15, 2020, 7:42am

And a couple more questions:

is it correct that the jury’s reward is formed on the basis of the final budget according to the formula: juror reward = (total budget * 0,05) / number of jurors?
if above is correct, is it correct that juror gets more reward if he / she and all his / her colleagues vote with 10?
is it a contest at all, when all participants take the first place?

What a fantastic solidarity of judges that I have not seen in any other contest:

bitjudge · December 15, 2020, 3:10pm

Please look for the #8 Wiki Renewal Contest Proposal voting result here.

The only reason why judges used to give 10 points to early work is that the quality of the materials in the previous contests was high.

If you think the judges are motivated to give high marks to earn more, how do you explain the wide range of marks in the last contest?

aicracy · December 15, 2020, 5:23pm

That is not about what I think and I also do not criticize your wiki work in general. Somebody must do that work and that is important. But your rewarding scheme forces the jurors to cheat. If they cheat or not depends on the quality of that concrete juror. Do not understand me in a wrong way - I’m not gonna fight with you. But rethink your rewarding system. The final budget and jurors rewards must be known in front of the contest.

bitjudge · December 15, 2020, 6:14pm

Okay, now I saw a constructive proposal from you, thanks.
We’ll think about changing the mechanism for rewarding the jury in the next contest.

aicracy · December 15, 2020, 6:16pm

Thanks for the adult approach. FreeTON needs it.

india · December 17, 2020, 4:09am

I think new jury members are also participating in voting this time.

Richi · December 17, 2020, 4:48pm

Submission for Wiki Renewal Contest

Statement

I confirm that I am a registered and approved user on the Free TON Wiki.

I confirm that my work has been done in good faith and meets the needs of the Free TON community.

I confirm that all the amounts and rewards presented below are calculated correctly. I confirm that I have been as objective as possible in evaluating my work and effort. I confirm that my assessment of my work has not been overstated.

I confirm that this submission meets the other mandatory requirements of the current Wiki Renewal Contest to which it is being submitted.

I understand that the above requirements are mandatory and if they are not met, the jury has the right to reject my work.

Contact data

Wiki username: Richi

Telegram username: @VGRichii

Submission data

Here I am attaching a screenshot with a table containing a report of my work:

sibirli · December 17, 2020, 4:55pm

Wiki Submission for Renewal Contest

Statement

I confirm that I am a registered and approved user on the Free TON Wiki.

I confirm that my work has been done in good faith and meets the needs of the Free TON community.

I confirm that all the amounts and rewards presented below are calculated correctly. I confirm that I have been as objective as possible in evaluating my work and effort. I confirm that my assessment of my work has not been overstated.

I confirm that this submission meets the other mandatory requirements of the current Wiki Renewal Contest to which it is being submitted.

I understand that the above requirements are mandatory and if they are not met, the jury has the right to reject my work.

Contact data

Wiki username: sibirli

Telegram username: @sibirli

Submission data

Here I am attaching a screenshot with a table containing a report of my work:

bitjudge · December 17, 2020, 5:48pm

Submission for Wiki Renewal Contest

Statement

I confirm that I am a registered and approved user on the Free TON Wiki.

I confirm that my work has been done in good faith and meets the needs of the Free TON community.

I confirm that all the amounts and rewards presented below are calculated correctly. I confirm that I have been as objective as possible in evaluating my work and effort. I confirm that my assessment of my work has not been overstated.

I confirm that this submission meets the other mandatory requirements of the current Wiki Renewal Contest to which it is being submitted.

I understand that the above requirements are mandatory and if they are not met, the jury has the right to reject my work.

Contact data

Wiki username: bitjudge

Telegram username: @everjob

Submission data

Here I am attaching a screenshot with a table containing a report of my work:

Medco · December 17, 2020, 7:06pm

Submission for Wiki Renewal Contest

Statement

I confirm that I am a registered and approved user on the Free TON Wiki.

I confirm that my work has been done in good faith and meets the needs of the Free TON community.

I confirm that all the amounts and rewards presented below are calculated correctly. I confirm that I have been as objective as possible in evaluating my work and effort. I confirm that my assessment of my work has not been overstated.

I confirm that this submission meets the other mandatory requirements of the current Wiki Renewal Contest to which it is being submitted.

I understand that the above requirements are mandatory and if they are not met, the jury has the right to reject my work.

Contact data

Wiki username: Medco

Telegram username: @olexandroverchuk

Submission data

Here I am attaching a screenshot with a table containing a report of my work:

Anesthesia · December 17, 2020, 11:46pm

Submission for Wiki Renewal Contest

Statement

I confirm that I am a registered and approved user on the Free TON Wiki.

I confirm that my work has been done in good faith and meets the needs of the Free TON community.

I confirm that all the amounts and rewards presented below are calculated correctly. I confirm that I have been as objective as possible in evaluating my work and effort. I confirm that my assessment of my work has not been overstated.

I confirm that this submission meets the other mandatory requirements of the current Wiki Renewal Contest to which it is being submitted.

I understand that the above requirements are mandatory and if they are not met, the jury has the right to reject my work.

Contact data

Wiki username: Anesthesia

Telegram username: @Anesthesia_v

Submission data

Here I am attaching a screenshot with a table containing a report of my work:

strunberg · December 18, 2020, 2:57am

Submission for Wiki Renewal Contest

Statement

I confirm that I am a registered and approved user on the Free TON Wiki.

I confirm that my work has been done in good faith and meets the needs of the Free TON community.

I confirm that all the amounts and rewards presented below are calculated correctly. I confirm that I have been as objective as possible in evaluating my work and effort. I confirm that my assessment of my work has not been overstated.

I confirm that this submission meets the other mandatory requirements of the current Wiki Renewal Contest to which it is being submitted.

I understand that the above requirements are mandatory and if they are not met, the jury has the right to reject my work.

Contact data

Wiki username: Strunberg

Telegram username: @arizall

Submission data

Here I am attaching a screenshot with a table containing a report of my work:

omic · December 18, 2020, 5:17am

Submission for Wiki Renewal Contest

Statement

I confirm that I am a registered and approved user on the Free TON Wiki.

I confirm that my work has been done in good faith and meets the needs of the Free TON community.

I confirm that all the amounts and rewards presented below are calculated correctly. I confirm that I have been as objective as possible in evaluating my work and effort. I confirm that my assessment of my work has not been overstated.

I confirm that this submission meets the other mandatory requirements of the current Wiki Renewal Contest to which it is being submitted.

I understand that the above requirements are mandatory and if they are not met, the jury has the right to reject my work.

Contact data

Wiki username: omic

Telegram username: @alicadmin

Submission data

Here I am attaching a screenshot with a table containing a report of my work: